UNP Insight • Professional Photographers • Visual Communication • Picture Editing
Who Decides What Stays Outside the Frame? Photography in a Vertical World
Vertical photography is hardly new. But when a photograph moves between newspapers, websites, social platforms and mobile screens, who decides which parts remain visible?
At United National Photographers (UNP), this is a practical question for commissioned photography. Our Start Up Loans assignment photographs show the distinction between composing an upright photograph and cropping an existing landscape — and why publishing formats belong in the photographic brief.
The Associated Press regularly publishes See the world in vertical: Top photos by AP photojournalists, a selection of photographs presented in upright frames. It offers a useful starting point for thinking about orientation, composition and context.
The photographs are interesting because of the information organised within their frames: the relationship between people, place, activity and the details around them. An upright can contain a complete and complex story.
That raises a practical question for photographers and the people commissioning them.
What happens when “vertical” stops describing the photographer’s chosen frame and starts describing the container into which an existing photograph must fit?
Upright Composition • Portrait • Workplace • Process • Detail
Vertical is an orientation. It is not a photographic treatment.
These five professional uprights share the same basic 2:3 shape, but they do very different things. The subject can be shown within the business, working, handling a product, engaged in a process or temporarily removed altogether so that another part of the story becomes the photograph.
One Photograph • Five Frames • Changing Context
What remains when the same photograph becomes progressively narrower?
This sequence uses the same original UNP photograph throughout. The purpose is to observe what remains visible as the boundaries move. These are illustrative reframings, rather than examples of crops imposed by a named platform. Compare the information retained inside each frame, rather than treating differences in display size as a measure of quality.
Published Use • Start Up Loans • British Business Bank • UK-Wide Photography
Published use from the Start Up Loans assignments
The business photographs in this Insight come from UNP assignments for the Start Up Loans Ambassador programme across more than one programme year. The current 2026/27 Start Up Loans Ambassadors include Salt Pig Sandwiches in York, CAHM in Farsley and Pretty Knits Wool Shop in Darlington. Other Start Up Loans businesses shown later in this article were photographed for earlier Ambassador programmes.
British Business Bank lists Start Up Loans among its government-backed programmes for UK businesses. The linked Ambassador profiles provide public context for Salt Pig, CAHM and Pretty Knits: the people, businesses and locations behind three of the assignments shown here.
The upright photographs in the assignment galleries are separately composed alternatives from these UNP assignments, rather than vertical crops of landscape images. The official profiles provide publication context; UNP’s photographs here show the range of compositions created during the commissions.
Uprights • Camera Formats • Picture Desks • Composition
Vertical seeing is not new
Photographers have made uprights for generations.
Looking down into the 6×6 square of a Hasselblad, composing within the 3:2 rectangle of a 35mm camera, or choosing a wider lens because the surroundings matter as much as the person standing within them, photography has always involved decisions about the frame.
You decide what belongs inside the photograph.
Inevitably, you also decide what does not.
Professional photographers were making upright photographs long before Instagram Stories, social feeds or smartphone screens became important publishing destinations. Picture editors and art directors needed genuine alternatives because different page shapes created different possibilities.
A horizontal photograph might work across several newspaper columns or across the width of a magazine page. An upright could work on a cover, occupy a narrower column, sit beside text or give an editor a completely different relationship between image, headline and page.
In many cases, making that alternative frame was simply part of professional photographic judgement: not making the same photograph twice, but giving the editor or commissioner another photograph capable of doing a different job.
Business Portraits • Workplace • Industry • Environmental Context
Context can survive inside an upright
A vertical frame does not automatically isolate a person from their surroundings. Shelving, stock, equipment, other people, working space and depth can all remain meaningful parts of the photograph when the photographer composes for them.
These are environmental editorial portraits, where the workplace remains part of the subject rather than becoming an interchangeable backdrop.
Darkroom • Newspapers • Picture Editing • Reproduction
Cropping is not new either
Photographers and picture editors have been cropping photographs for generations. The moving edge of the frame is not a digital invention.
Long before social media or content-management systems, a photograph could be tightened under a darkroom enlarger, trimmed on a newspaper picture desk or reshaped by a magazine designer.
A horizontal photograph might become a tighter horizontal. A square might become a vertical. A distracting element might be removed, a page shape might demand another proportion or the story might simply become stronger when the frame was tightened.
The edge of the photograph has never been sacred.
So cropping itself is not the new story.
Mobile Publishing • Social Media • 4:5 • 9:16 • Screens
What is newer is the vertical destination
Vertical photography is old. What is newer is the scale and frequency with which photographs are encountered inside vertical digital containers.
Mobile news, social platforms — including Instagram Stories — and smartphones held naturally upright have made vertical containers far more common places in which photographs are encountered.
A photograph that once needed to work on a newspaper page, magazine spread or desktop website may now also be expected to occupy a 4:5 social feed, a square preview, a mobile card or a 9:16 screen.
That does not mean every photograph should simply be made vertical.
Nor does it mean a horizontal photograph can always be turned into one safely afterwards.
The destination has become part of the photographic problem.
Photographer • Picture Editor • Commissioner • Platform
What has changed is who may choose the frame
The more interesting change is not simply that photographs are being seen vertically.
It is who gets to decide that they should be vertical.
A photographer may make a carefully composed 3:2 horizontal photograph in which people, place, architecture and peripheral detail have been deliberately organised within the frame.
That photograph may then travel through a picture editor, communications team, designer, website, content-management system, social platform, app, thumbnail or responsive layout before being presented inside another shape.
Sometimes a person makes that decision.
Sometimes a layout crops the visible image automatically. A website can, for example, use a fixed-shape image container that fills its available space while hiding parts of the photograph outside it.
And sometimes the photographer who decided what belonged in the original frame has no involvement at all.
Context • Environmental Photography • Editorial Meaning
The Death of the Periphery?
Information does not live only in the middle of a photograph.
Take a wide photograph of a person standing inside a factory.
The person may be the obvious subject, but the machinery around them tells us where they work. The distance behind them tells us something about scale. Another employee at the edge may tell us that this is a functioning workplace rather than an empty backdrop. Signage may identify the site.
Pipes, equipment, architecture, people and apparently insignificant details can collectively establish context.
Begin narrowing the frame and the person may remain.
But the photograph does not necessarily remain the same.
A tighter crop may make the image stronger. A face becomes larger. An expression becomes clearer. Distraction disappears and emotion intensifies.
But there is a trade-off.
What has been removed may be as significant as what remains.
Authenticity • Context • Editorial Judgement
Cropping can change meaning without changing the remaining pixels.
Cropping a photograph does not necessarily falsify it.
Nothing needs to be cloned, generated, removed with software or altered by artificial intelligence. Every pixel remaining inside the crop can be completely authentic.
Yet an authentic photograph can still acquire a different meaning when its boundaries change.
A large crowd can become a handful of people.
A person surrounded by others can appear isolated.
An industrial portrait can lose the industry.
A photograph of an event can become a photograph of an individual.
That does not make cropping unethical. Picture editors have always made decisions about emphasis, relevance and available space.
But it does make cropping an editorial act.
This distinction also matters when considering image provenance and photographic context: knowing where a file came from does not, by itself, explain what a later crop has left outside the frame.
Place • Product • Business Portraits • Environmental Context
Place can remain part of the portrait
An upright need not reduce a business portrait to a face against an anonymous background. Product, shop interior, colour, signage and the physical premises can remain active parts of the photograph.
Upright Composition • Height • Depth • Visual Judgement
Vertical photography is not the problem
This is not an argument against vertical photography.
It is an argument for thinking about the frame before treating it as interchangeable.
A photograph deliberately made vertically can contain enormous amounts of context.
A skilled photographer can use height, foreground, background, layering and depth every bit as deliberately as another photographer uses the width of a horizontal frame.
People are vertical. Buildings rise vertically. A figure beneath a large structure can gain scale from an upright composition. Several people can be layered through depth. Signage or architecture can sit above a subject rather than beside them.
A photographer working carefully within that frame is not necessarily throwing context away.
The more interesting problem begins when a photograph composed for one shape is expected to become every other shape afterwards.
Alternative Frames • Photographer Judgement • Composition
Recomposed, not merely reorientated
Ask an experienced photographer for a horizontal and an upright and you should not necessarily receive the same photograph twice with the camera turned through 90 degrees.
A good upright is usually recomposed, not merely reorientated.
UNP’s IKEA assignments provide another example of independently composed portrait and landscape photographs within a consistent corporate image library.
The photographer may move.
They may come closer or step back.
The subject may need to shift within the scene.
Information that sat beside the subject in a horizontal frame may need to appear above, below, behind or in front of them in the upright.
A different focal length may work better.
The photographer may wait for another moment entirely.
The ingredients can remain similar.
Their relationship changes.
Foreground • Background • Depth • Process • Product
The vertical frame can reorganise information
Foreground objects, shelving, products, the working environment and the person can occupy different levels of the same upright. Rather than simply removing information from the sides of a horizontal photograph, the composition can redistribute it through height and depth.
People • Activity • Place • Business Identity • Environment
The subject is not always the whole story
A professional upright can move between a person, their work, surroundings, equipment, animals, vehicles and business identity. The orientation may remain constant while the information the photographer chooses to emphasise changes completely.
Picture Desk • Publishing Destination • Format Planning
The destination has become part of the photographic brief
For generations, picture desks asked photographers for horizontals and uprights because editors wanted choices.
Curiously, that old picture-desk habit now looks remarkably modern.
The practical task is to identify the likely destinations before the assignment, then decide what needs to be photographed differently.
The answer is not necessarily to photograph every moment four times.
It is to recognise which subjects deserve a separately composed alternative.
There is an important difference between supplying several file shapes and making several photographs.
Compose for the frame rather than relying automatically on the crop.
Press • PR • Corporate • Event • Professional Photographers
What does this mean for people commissioning photographers?
For picture editors, the changing frame raises questions about context and the visual record.
For PR and communications teams, it creates a more immediate practical problem:
one photograph is increasingly being asked to do too many jobs.
Cropping one master photograph into several formats can work perfectly well. Sometimes there is sufficient space and nothing important is lost.
But it should not automatically be assumed.
A press photographer, PR photographer, corporate photographer or event photographer may be creating photographs that will ultimately appear in several very different spaces.
The Start Up Loans assignments shown in this Insight also demonstrate a wider commissioning point. Businesses were photographed in different UK locations and across different programme years, while the communications requirement remained connected. UNP’s multi-location photographer service and UK photographer coverage show how one central Picture Desk can coordinate local photographers, briefing and delivery across towns, cities and regions without treating every assignment as an unrelated one-off.
Knowing the likely destinations allows the photographer to decide which subjects and moments deserve alternative compositions and which are better left alone. For the wider communications requirement, see UNP’s guide to professional photographers for UK communications teams.
Before the assignment, tell the UNP Picture Desk where the photographs will appear, which people, products, signs or surroundings must remain visible, and whether layouts need space for headlines or graphics. Supply any fixed aspect ratios or example layouts. This gives the photographer a clearer basis for deciding when a separate composition will be more useful than another crop.
To discuss those requirements, contact the UNP Picture Desk.
Perhaps the first question should therefore not be:
Portrait or landscape?
Perhaps it should be:
Where is this photograph going — and what does the audience need to understand when it gets there?
Photography • Choice • Context • The Frame
Back to the vertical world
The Associated Press’s recurring selection of outstanding upright photographs is not evidence that horizontal photography is disappearing.
Nor should it be.
It is a reminder that photographers can make complete, complex and powerful photographs inside a vertical frame.
Vertical photography is not new.
Cropping is not new.
What is newer is the number of vertical destinations a photograph may be expected to inhabit — and the possibility that its final frame may be chosen long after the photographer has made it.
Vertical photography can be beautiful, informative, powerful and complete.
Horizontal photography can be intimate.
Square photography can contain extraordinary depth.
No aspect ratio owns truth.
The important distinction is whether the frame has been chosen for the photograph or whether the photograph has subsequently been forced to fit the frame.
Every photograph has always left something outside its edges.
What may be changing is who gets to move those edges afterwards.
Who decides what stays outside the frame?